Umina wins debate against Woy Woy South

Teams from Umina Public School and Woy Woy South Public School went head-to-head in round three of the NSW Premier's Debating Challenge on Friday, July 19, at Umina Public School.

The topic was "That Australia should ban people under 18 from working as models".

A coin toss resulted in Umina Public School being the negative team.

"Both teams constructed convincing arguments and delivered an entertaining debate," said Umina Public School debating coordinator Ms Rebecca Rodwell.

"Some arguments put forward from the opposition were that young models wear excess make up, use botox and the fact that modelling can ruin relationships with their parents.

"Umina's arguments were that modelling can build confidence in young people; it provides part time jobs that can pay for a better education and develops positive health choices combined with social skills.

"The strong persuasive language used by Umina successfully convinced the adjudicator as Umina won this debate."

Ms Rodwell said the team had shown a "continual improvement of their debating skills".

"Their ability to accept constructive feedback and regular attendance at our weekly workshop meetings is exceptional.

"We have a team that consists of seven members and we rotate speakers for each debate.

"The team is very supportive of each other, a wonderful bunch of talented students.

"As the host school we were fortunate to have a fantastic audience from stage three.

"The students are preparing for the final round to be held at Woy Woy South Public School later this term," said Ms Rodwell.

Newsletter, 23 Jul 2013

Lyn Davis, Umina Public School