Phone 4325 7369     Fax 4339 2307     Email us.

Skip Navigation Links.
Collapse Issue 422 - 26 Jun 2017Issue 422 - 26 Jun 2017
Collapse  NEWS NEWS
Liberal funding advert 'hugely inflated', say teachers
Council refuses caravan park expansion
Police tell riders to wait till dawn
Bob Puffett to stand for council
Community plan generated in Pearl Beach
State Budget shows little care for the Peninsula
More buses on route 64
No sign of road funding, says Tesch
National parks suffer from Budget, says association
Action against former Gosford Council staff not ruled out
Proposal to build childcare centre in Booker Bay
Community Group makes submission to Council
Council appoints senior staff ahead of elections
Missing children found
Young Australian of the Year addresses Rotary clubs
CWA hall painted for first time in 40 years
Grant to Mingaletta
Council candidate signals ongoing dredging campaign
Co-working space to open in Umina
Collapse  OPINION OPINION
Audit outcome - more about appearance than substance
Collapse  FORUM FORUM
What about the cars and nurturing the plants
'Ex-employee' answers council inquiry
I will fight for the Peninsula
Collapse  HEALTH HEALTH
Aged care provider surveys the community
Hospital hosts free exercise classes
Talk about diets for autistic children
Flown to Royal North Shore
Donations to funeral costs
Yoga classes held at surf club
Collapse  ARTS ARTS
Calling young Peninsula artists
Photographic competition at Patonga
Locals win regional photo competition
Lord of the Strings at folk club
Lightness and transparency in new exhibition
Collapse  EDUCATION EDUCATION
Gonski billboard visits schools
Band performs eight songs
Students visit wildlife park
Excursion for World Environment Day
Parade was case of 'happily ever after'
Celebrating Naidoc Week
Horse riding for special students
Pyjama day
School raises more than $500
Students attend netball cup
Learning about a sustainable lifestyle
Collapse  SPORT SPORT
Surf clubs take out major awards
Junior floorball open held on Peninsula
Gym coach to perform in Denmark
Lions defeated by Terrigal at Woy Woy
Katelyn returns from Thailand with placings
English soccer club to hold coaching camp
Umina bowling championship
Major singles
Major singles
Collapse  HISTORY HISTORY
When Woy Woy controlled its own destiny

Audit outcome - more about appearance than substance

The residents of the former Gosford Council have been told it is highly unusual for an auditor to write a disclaimer instead of offer an "opinion" on its financial statements.

It has been portrayed as letting administrator Mr Ian Reynolds, chief Mr Rob Noble and their senior management team "off the hook" in terms of their Local Government Act responsibilities to vouch for the accuracy of the former Gosford Council's financial statements.

It also gives their no-doubt well-paid auditor, Price Waterhouse Coopers, an "out" - if management could not provide sufficient evidence, the auditor could not possibly be expected to provide an opinion as to the validity of the books.

Both gentlemen lit a fire in March when they announced they had uncovered "serious control weaknesses" and had to revalue the former Gosford Council's assets downward by $1.38 billion.

They made it clear that they did not believe any current member of staff had done anything wrong.

Before they drew their line in the sand and stopped answering questions about the Gosford accounts, they explained that the revaluation issues related mainly to a double-counting of manholes in 2010 and an over-valuation of bulk earthworks.

Their great discoveries were more about incompetence, human error and sloppiness, than any great financial scandal ... but the mud stuck.

They also explained that the control issues related to software, believed to be used by local councils across the state since the late 1980s, that had an "option" switched off at some stage which allowed for multiple parties, including third parties, to make changes to data without leaving an evidence trail.

When pressed, Mr Noble said he was unable to confirm whether any data changes had been made, nor could he confirm they hadn't.

The matters were referred to ICAC, police and the NSW Auditor, although Mr Noble at no stage named those external parties.

Mr Noble has not answered questions about whether the same "forensic" process was applied to the accounts of the former Wyong Council.

The auditor chosen from the short-list of candidates provided by the NSW Government, and in particular the Office of Premier and Cabinet that has controlled the whole council amalgamation process, Price Waterhouse Coopers, just happened to have been Wyong's auditor.

No fresh eyes, no independent, forensic third-party scrutiny has been applied to the accounts of the former Wyong Council.

As a result, it is unlikely we will ever know whether or not they double-counted their manholes or overvalued their road base or made similar errors.

Victors write history and there is now mounting evidence that the "amalgamation" of Gosford and Wyong LGAs has clearly been a takeover of the southern LGA by the Liberal-dominated Wyong Council.

In a corporate takeover, the target frequently has its assets revalued in the acquisition, for purposes that suit the purchaser.

It has been no different in this case.

Not one of over 40 senior managers from the Gosford Council remains, according to former Gosford deputy mayor Craig Doyle.

Former Gosford councillors across the political spectrum are incensed that the NSW Government-appointed Administrator and CEO have implied poor financial practices that have opened the way for targeted political advertising that could, at the very least, confuse the general public if not mislead it.

Independent financial experts have told Peninsula News it is unlikely any third party, ICAC, the police or the Auditor-General, will look further into the management of the former council's books or take action.

The former Gosford councillors have spent the past 13 months silenced as members of the tokenistic Local Representation Committee, now dissolved.

None chose to stay outside the administrator's regime and speak on-the-record about the loss of their constituents' democracy during that time.

Now they are no longer sworn to silence, it is too late to lead the public to fully understand what has already been lost: the dissolution of all community committees and their replacement with a website and hand-picked consultative groups; the appointment of a senior executive team on long-term contracts hand-picked by representatives of the current State Government; the diminution of representation to only three councillors per around 66,000 residents; the appointment of a Coordinator-General to ram through a regional plan that ignores the diverse and unique concerns and needs of the many communities that make up that region.

Each of those unique communities, Woy Woy Peninsula in particular, has now become part of a Mike Baird experiment that has the potential to impact our social, economic and environmental fabric and wellbeing for decades.

Comments


Add a comment
Comments entered here may be published in the Forum section of Peninsula News. Name, full residential address and daytime telephone number are required, but only name and suburb will be published. This is a moderated forum: Contributions will not appear here until they are approved by the editor. Contributions may appear in an edited form.


Name:
 
Address:
Suburb:
Telephone:
Comment:
 

 
  • BaysideP

    pictures/300_BaysideP.jpg

    BaysideP

  • BobP

    pictures/300_BobP.jpg

    BobP

  • GropP

    pictures/300_GropP.jpg

    GropP

  • BudgetP

    pictures/300_BudgetP.jpg

    BudgetP

  • ParksP

    pictures/300_ParksP.jpg

    ParksP

  • ChildP

    pictures/300_ChildP.jpg

    ChildP

  • ExecsP

    pictures/300_ExecsP.jpg

    ExecsP

  • YoungAusP

    pictures/300_YoungAusP.jpg

    YoungAusP

  • HallP

    pictures/300_HallP.jpg

    HallP

  • CommonP

    pictures/300_CommonP.jpg

    CommonP

  • SurveyP

    pictures/300_SurveyP.jpg

    SurveyP

  • DryP

    pictures/300_DryP.jpg

    DryP

  • StairsP

    pictures/300_StairsP.jpg

    StairsP

  • WilsonP

    pictures/300_WilsonP.jpg

    WilsonP

  • ExposureP

    pictures/300_ExposureP.jpg

    ExposureP

  • StringsP

    pictures/300_StringsP.jpg

    StringsP

  • BandP

    pictures/300_BandP.jpg

    BandP

  • BushP

    pictures/300_BushP.jpg

    BushP

  • EnviroP

    pictures/300_EnviroP.jpg

    EnviroP

  • FairyP

    pictures/300_FairyP.jpg

    FairyP

  • RidingP

    pictures/300_RidingP.jpg

    RidingP

  • PJdayP

    pictures/300_PJdayP.jpg

    PJdayP

  • WormsP

    pictures/300_WormsP.jpg

    WormsP

  • AwardsP

    pictures/300_AwardsP.jpg

    AwardsP

  • LachlanP

    pictures/300_LachlanP.jpg

    LachlanP

  • SmithP

    pictures/300_SmithP.jpg

    SmithP

  • WestHamCampP

    pictures/300_WestHamCampP.jpg

    WestHamCampP

  • SinglesP

    pictures/300_SinglesP.jpg

    SinglesP

  • LadiesP

    pictures/300_LadiesP.jpg

    LadiesP



Search this website

What's On
.
<November 2017>
SunMonTueWedThuFriSat
2930311234
567891011
12131415161718
19202122232425
262728293012
3456789
(Click for details)


Skip Navigation Links.

Skip Navigation Links.
  Copyright © 2017 Peninsula Community Access Newspaper Inc